Click Here for Daily Specials, Events, and Updates on Facebook!

Mother's Day:  May 13th, 2012
We will be serving brunch from 10:30 til 2pm and then change over to our dinner menu from 1pm-9pm. brunch will start at $9. We will have some wonderful specials for dinner. Including Pan Seared Sea Scallops paired w/ White Cliffs Awosting White grape sauce, green beans and toasted almonds. We have great Dry aged beef and lovely Halibut on the menu with greens from our local farms. Make your reservations now! Call us on 845 255 4151
Seasonally inspired, homemade menu with locally sourced ingredients,

daily specials and house-made desserts.

A Sample of our Dinner menu 
(Lunch, Beer, Wine, and Cocktails below)


LUNCH MENU          DINNER MENU          DESSERTS          BEERS          WINES           COCKTAILS   

Dinner

 Starters

PEI Mussels 14

In a light Sherry wine broth, fresh tomatoes, shallots, garlic, herbs

Shrimp Cocktail 12

Half a dozen shrimp, served on ice with cocktail sauce

Classic Caesar salad 9

Romaine lettuce, with shaved Parmigianino Reggiano and dressing, add anchovies $1

Roasted Beet Salad 12

With sliced radish, shaved fennel, Acorn Hill Farmstead chevre,

Jumbo Lump Crab cakes 14

Panko Encrusted, Dijon remoulade, chive oil and red pepper coulis.

Calamari 12

Fried in seasoned breadcrumbs, served with spicy marinara sauce

Antipasto 12

Imported meats and cheeses, house pickled vegetables and accompaniments, enough to share

Cheese Platter 12
Chef's choice of Local Cheeses from Acorn Hill Farm Coach Farms  and Sprout Crek

French onion soup 6

Caramelized Onions, Sherry wine and beef stock, melted cheese over crouton

Daily soup special

Please ask server

We are pleased to serve our homemade bread with dinner

entrees

Lasagna 16

Layers of fresh pasta, ground sirloin and pork,

Marinara, herbs, imported cheeses and Ricotta

Eggplant Parmigiano 16

Breaded and seasoned eggplant, lightly fried and layered with fresh tomato sauce, mozzarella, ricotta, and Pecorino Romano, side of pasta

Clams and Linguine 18

Littleneck clams, white wine broth, herbs, over a bed of linguine

Seared Salmon 21

Seared in clarified butter, with a white wine and cream dill sauce and asparagus

Pan Seared Duck Breast 23

Spiced Port Wine and Drunken Cherry Sauce, served with Tonight's Side and Tonight's Potato. Chef recommends rare to medium for optimal flavor and tenderness.

Rack of Lamb 28

Marinated in Spices to the Chef's Specifications for the Season

Brick Chicken 24

All Natural Half Chicken Roasted under a "Brick" to maintain the ultimate moisture and tenderness

ALL STEAKS ARE SERVED WITH TODAY’S SIDE & POTATO, OR SALAD

Usda prime porterhouse market price. 28 0z both the Strip and Filet, marbled to perfection for optimal flavor, grilled to your liking

Rib-eye 32

20 oz Well-marbled Certified Angus, grilled to your liking

New York strip 26

14 oz Well-marbled Certified Angus, grilled to your liking

Ossobuco 22

Center-cut PORK Hind-shank, braised and roasted with vegetables, served with wild porcini risotto

Veal saltimbocca 23

Authentically prepared with Prosciutto di Parma, sage, white wine sauce

Penne alla Vodka

Sautéed Pancetta, Shallots flambéed with Vodka, Green Peas, Marinara and splash of cream:

With Shrimp 23, With Chicken 21

Shrimp Scampi 21

Linguini, white wine, shallots, garlic, butter, parsley

 

Loin and Tail 38

9 oz Hereford Beef Filet Mignon with a Spiced Red Wine Sauce, 6 oz Maine Lobster Tail, served with Tonight’s Side and Tonight’s Potato

TuthillHouse Burger 15

8oz Grass-fed beef on a Brioche roll, shallot and house made herbed mayonnaise, pickle with fries or salad: choice of gruyere or cheddar

 Several Seasonal Vegetarian and Chef's specials Available

Sides

Seasonal Sauteed Greens

Sautéed Mushrooms and Onions 5

Fingerling Potatoes Pan Roasted in duck fat 6

Greens and Veggies Local as available

 

House made desserts

Seasonal Tart (Apple, Pear, clove, cinnamon, cardamom, bourbon and maple) 8

Ricotta Cheesecake 5

Tiramisu 6

Cannoli 5

Flourless Chocolate Cake 6

 Homemade Ice Cream 4

French Vanilla or  Chocolate

 

Beverages

Please ask your server for our cocktail, beer and wine list

Coca-cola, Diet Coke, Dr Pepper, Sprite, Ginger Ale, Iced tea $1.95

House iced-tea, ask server $1.95

Manhattan Special –Espresso Soda $2.50

Coffee $1.75

Espresso $2

Cappuccino $3.25

Hot Tea $1.95

New York City Egg Cream $3

San Pelligrino 1L $5

San Pelligrino 500ml $3

Saratoga Water Non-Sparkling 28oz $4.50

Herbal teas are available

 

LUNCH

Roasted Beet Salad 12

With sliced garden veggies, shaved fennel, Acorn Hill Farmstead chevre, locally sourced greens and TuthillHouse vinaigrette

Classic Caesar salad 9

Romaine lettuce, with shaved Parmigianino Reggiano and dressing, add anchovies $1

Antipasto 12

Imported meats and cheeses, house pickled vegetables and accompaniments, enough to share

Cheese Platter 12
Chef's choice of Local cheeses from Acorn Hill Farm Coach Farms and Sprout Creek

French onion soup 6

Caramelized Onions, Sherry wine and chicken stock, melted cheese over crouton

Daily soup special

Please ask server

 

Fresh Mozzarella 9

Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers, Grilled Eggplant, sundried tomato and roasted garlic puree, Toasted house-made Baguette

Pastrami sandwich 13

Pastrami, rye bread, mustard with pickle

Pastrami Reuben 14

Sauerkraut, Russian dressing, Swiss cheese, Rye Bread with Pickle

TuthillHouse Burger 12

8oz Hudson Valley Cattle Company Grass-fed beef on a Brioche roll, house made shallot and herbed mayonnaise, pickle with fries or salad: choice of gruyere or cheddar

The ‘Gristy’ Burger 14

The TuthillHouse Burger with fried egg, Acorn Hill Farmstead chevre, house made shallot and herbed mayonnaise, pickled red onions with fries or salad

Lasagna 16

Layers of fresh pasta, ground sirloin and pork, marinara, herbs, imported cheeses and ricotta

Eggplant Parmigianino 16

Breaded and seasoned eggplant, lightly fried and layered with fresh tomato sauce, mozzarella, and Pecorino Romano, side of pasta

Philly Cheese steak 10

Fish ‘n Chips 14

Several Seasonal Vegetarian and Chef's Specials Available ask your server

 

WINES

SPARKLING WINE                                                                  By  Glass/Bottle

LE COLTURE Prosecco di Valdobbiadene Brut, Fagher,Veneto

JOEL FALMET Champagne Brut

BRICCO DEL SOLE Moscato d' Asti, Piemonte (375ml)

WHITE WINE

SANDY COVE Sauvignon Blanc, Malborough, NZ '

CHANTE CIGALE Vin de Pays L'Apostrophe Blanc, Roussanne, Clairette, So. Rhone '08

D'ORSARIA Pinot Grigio, Friuli,

ROBIBERO ask your server for selection

           

WHITECLIFF ask your server for selection

CASCINA DEGLI ULIVI, Gavi, Cortese di Gavi, Piemonte '08

DIERBERG Chardonnay, Santa Maria Valley '07

RED WINE

CHANTE CIGALE VdP L'Apostrophe Rosé, Grenache, Cinsault, So. Rhone '09

JOHNSON FAMILY Pinot Noir, Sonoma Coast '08

CHANTE CIGALE VdP L'Apostrophe Rouge, Grenache, Cinsault, Syrah, So. Rhone '08

THE PEOPLE'S Zin, Zinfandel, CA '08

WHITECLIFF Gamay Noir, Hudson Valley

ROBERT SINSKEY Pinot Noir, Los Caneros, Napa '07

CROSBY Cabernet Savignon, San Joaquin Co. '09

NORTON RIDGE Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa '07

           

 

JEANNE MARIE, Merlot, California '08

IL COLLE Rosso di Montalcino, Sangiovese, Tuscany '07

 

PORTS

QUINTA DO INFANTADO Ruby, Douro, Portugal

QUINTA DO INFANTADO Tawny, Douro, Portugal

Sustainable, Biodynamic, Organic, Portion of Profits to Social Causes

COCKTAILS

TUTHILLHOUSE COCKTAIL Rye, Maple, Mint, Lemon and Angostura Bitters

THE BLINKER Old Overholt Rye Whiskey, Grapefruit juice and raspberry syrup

TUTHILLHOUSE CIDER SMASH Hudson Baby Bourbon, Apple Cider and Fee Brothers Bitters

           

 

ELECTRIC EGG CREAM Crème de Cocao, house infused vanilla Stolichnaya, Cream and Seltzer

ST. GERMAIN GIN & TONIC New Amsterdam Gin, St. Germain Liquor, tonic and lime

HUDSON HOT TODDY Hudson Four Grain Bourbon, Honey, Lemon, Cinnamon and Clove

Ask your bar-tender for her delightful nightly drink specials

BEER

DRAFT

Keagan Ales

Budweiser          3.5

Brooklyn, Please Ask Server     5.5

Ommegang, Please Ask Server     5.5

BOTTLE

Southern Tier IPA    4

Stella Artois     4

Sam Adams     4

           

 

Samuel Smith Taddy Porter       5

Brooklyn Black Chocolate Stout         5

 

Special Seasonal Beers, Cocktails, Wine and Spirits